List of Indicators for Measurement and Evaluation of CS in LAC

Publication date: 2007

LIST OF INDICATORS FOR MEASUREMENT AND EVALUATION OF CS IN LAC CS FINANCIAL INDICATORS Objective: To ensure adequate and secure funding for family planning contraceptives. SUB-OBJECTIVE / RESULT INDICATOR INDICATOR CALCULATION DATA SOURCE FREQUENCY EXPECTED RESULT NOTES Decrease the gap between required financial needs and actual funding ƒ Percent and absolute difference between current requirements and available funds in current year (year X) ƒ Percent and absolute difference between projected requirements and projected actual funds 5 years from current date (year X+5) ƒ [Available funds for year X (or X+5) / Required funds for year X (or X+5)] * 100 ƒ [Available funds for year X (or X+5)] – [Required funds for year X (or X+5)] DHS, consumption data, PipeLine, SPECTRUM, or other Annually TBD Analysis should be completed by sector Increase efficiency in use of allocated funds ƒ Percent of budget allocated versus funds requested ƒ Percent of actual public sector expenditures versus allocated funds ƒ [Allocated Budget / Funds requested] * 100 ƒ [Actual Public Sector Expenditures / Allocated Funds] * 100 Ministry of Health, Ministry of Finance Annually Government or Ministry of Health Improve processes ƒ Phaseout plan exists ƒ Budget line item exists ƒ Phaseout plan: Y/N ƒ Budget line item: Y/N CS Yes, by date determined by CS Committee Develop checklist Expand financing options ƒ Percent of contraceptive expenditures funded by sources other than donors ƒ Number of new funding sources providing resources to programs formally funded by donors Ministry of Health, Ministry of Finance Annually Specify by source CS PROCUREMENT INDICATORS Objective: Ensure efficient and effective procurement systems. SUB-OBJECTIVE / RESULT INDICATOR INDICATOR CALCULATION DATA SOURCE FREQUENCY EXPECTED RESULT NOTES Ensure the appropriate range of methods are procured to meet country needs ƒ Minimum list of contraceptive products selected ƒ Products included on essential drug list ƒ Minimum list of products selected: Y/N ƒ Products included on EDL: Y/N Ministry of Health Once Ensure efficient procurement ƒ Procurement plan exists ƒ Tracking mechanism exists to monitor status of products during procurement process ƒ Contraceptive costs as a percent of international benchmarks ƒ Contraceptive costs versus lowest local provider ƒ Percent of procurement process costs versus contraceptive cost ƒ Analysis carried out to determine optimal mix of centralized versus decentralized purchases ƒ Percent of purchases made centrally and directly by facility ƒ Procurement plan exists?: Y/N ƒ Tracking mechanism exists?: Y/N ƒ [Price paid for contraceptives / Int’l reference price] * 100 ƒ [Price paid for contraceptives / Lowest price paid for contraceptives from local provider] * 100 ƒ [Procurement process costs / Contraceptive cost] * 100 ƒ Analysis carried out to determine optimal mix?: Y/N ƒ [Amt. of centralized procurement / Total procurement] * 100 ƒ [Amt. of procurement by facility / Total procurement] *100 Program records UNFPA, MSH Previous tenders, current quotes Accounting system, procurement agents bid or cost Program records MOH or NGO finance records Decentralized versus centralized systems; crown agents versus direct government procurement Link to logistics indicators Ensure effective procurement ƒ Supplier fill rate: percent of orders that arrive completely filled within a specified time period ƒ [Number of orders filled in year X / Total number of orders in year X] * 100 Program records Bi-Annually CS LOGISTICS INDICATORS Objective: Improve supply chains capacity for delivering adequate supplies to service delivery points. SUB- OBJECTIVE/RESULT INDICATOR INDICATOR CALCULATION DATA SOURCE FREQUENCY EXPECTED RESULT NOTES Maintain product availability at facility level ƒ Percent of facilities that have contraceptives within reserve level ƒ [Number of facilities with stock levels within the reserve level / Total number of facilities] * 100 Facility registers, spot checks, LMIS At least quarterly Improve forecasting accuracy ƒ Forecasts use consumption data ƒ Forecasts carried out annually ƒ Forecast accuracy: percent discrepancy between forecast and actual use ƒ Forecasts use consumption data: Y/N ƒ Forecasts carried out annually: Y/N ƒ {[Estimated need – actual use of contraceptives] / [Estimated need]} * 100 Forecast and consumption records Annually Ensure timely and accurate data reporting through LMIS ƒ LMIS forms include 4 essential data items: consumption, adjustments/losses, and stock on hand, quantity of contraceptives not dispensed due to stock- outs (unfilled prescriptions) ƒ LMIS reporting rate ƒ LMIS data quality - % discrepancy between inventory stock cards and LMIS reports ƒ LMIS forms include 4 essential data items?: Y/N ƒ [Number of facilities reporting LMIS data / Total number of facilities] * 100 ƒ {[LMIS report count – Stock record count] / [Stock record count]} * 100 Ensure adequate and sustainable human capacity ƒ Warehousing ƒ Distribution ƒ CS POLITICAL COMMITMENT INDICATORS Objective: Strengthen political commitment for sustainable family planning services and contraceptive security SUB- OBJECTIVE/RESULT INDICATOR DATA SOURCE FREQUENCY EXPECTED RESULT NOTES Strengthen advocacy efforts around CS ƒ Number of civil society organizations advocating for FP and CS ƒ Number & type of advocacy events Key informant interviews Annually Distinguish by central and local level Strengthen legal / regulatory framework and policy environment in favor of CS ƒ DAIA Committee institutionalized ƒ Funded national budget line item ƒ Local funding for contraceptives (in decentralized settings) ƒ Contraceptives established as a “strategic commodity” Ministry of Health (central and local) Annually Yes CS MARKET SEGMENTATION INDICATORS Objective: Ensure whole market approach towards contraceptive security SUB-OBJECTIVE / RESULT INDICATOR INDICATOR CALCULATION DATA SOURCE FREQUENCY EXPECTED RESULT NOTES Understand current market structure and address inefficiencies that may exist ƒ Analysis carried out to understand current market structure (based on CPR, source, unment need, method mix, education, age, geographic, socioeconomic status) ƒ CS Committee defines options for future market structure ƒ Action plan developed to move from current to desired market structure ƒ Action plan developed to move from current to desired market structure: Y/N Secondary data analysis of DHS, RHS; CS Committees; Trends Every five years. Rationalize resource use in contraceptive market ƒ Percent of those with means relying on MOH for contraceptives ƒ Source of contraceptives for users ƒ Is there an intentional change in the source(s) of contraceptives for users?: Y/N Secondary analysis of DHS; exit interviews; trends Every five years. Increase access to contraceptives among underserved groups ƒ Unmet need, intenders, and/or traditional method users ƒ Source of contraceptives for users ƒ CPR ƒ [Number of users with unmet need / CPR] * 100 Secondary analysis of DHS; service statistics from facilities Every five years Illustrative Activities for Attaining Contraceptive Security FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY ƒ Develop phaseout plans for contraceptive methods, for products, and for years. ƒ Identify financial need based on annual forecasting. o Prepare scenarios based on prices, method mix, and different sources, and identify key assumptions that are used (e.g. consumption versus demography). ƒ Identify and expand the financial mechanisms o Budget line item for the MOH o Social Security o Private Insurance o Commercial Sector / others o User fees / voluntary contributions Determine feasibility (barriers, limits, and opportunities) of financial options and identify specific actions for their implementation. ƒ Achieve a potential cost savings through a change in the method mix. PROCUREMENT ƒ Map out internal procurement processes by source (e.g. UNFPA, local producers, international suppliers) and by sector (MOH, Social Security, NGO) ƒ Identify different options/variables for procurement: o Compare different internal procurement procedures between various sectors and discuss viable options for effective and efficient procurement. o Discuss advantages/disadvantages of public sector procurement versus other mechanisms. o Advantages/disadvantages of local suppliers versus international ones. ƒ Evaluate the benefits, costs, legal and regulatory issues, and prices associated with different procurement options ƒ Select a minimum range of contraceptive methods to offer and include them on the essential drugs list (public sector) o Consider the availability of different contraceptives among suppliers when the decision is to be made about what to include on the essential drugs list. ƒ Develop standard operating procedures for procurement (MOH) o Product specification, supply processes, etc. LOGISTICS ƒ Analyze the effectiveness of the logistics system o Distribution - Potential cost savings for different distribution systems • Effectiveness of the transport system for ensuring product availability • Reach of the supply chain - Warehouse conditions (space, ventilation, etc.) o Inventory management - Automation - Analysis of the minimum storage requirements for the inventory o Logistics Management Information System - Automated system o Needs Estimates - Make sure they are based on consumption data ƒ Analyze the impact of integrating logistics functions to ensure the availability of contraceptives. o Protect the ground that has been gained in contraceptive logistics systems - Estimate need based on consumption data - Ensure that the information system for contraceptives is maintained throughout the integration process ƒ Analyze the impact of decentralization on all aspects of the logistics functions o Maintain centralized procurement (include price negotiations) o Evaluate the financing and administration of the distribution system, based on the procurement options available. MARKET SEGMENTATION ƒ Understand the current market structure with respect to prioritizing scarce resources and maintaining or increasing CPR ƒ Discuss options for future market structures, if it is deemed necessary. ƒ If a change is necessary, develop action plans to move from the current market structure to the desired one. POLITICAL COMMITMENT ƒ Develop a political commitment through evidence-based advocacy o Strengthen the civil society’s advocacy capacity to include issues related to CS o Tie advocacy to reducing poverty, maternal mortality, infant mortality, and HIV/AIDS o Quantify the costs of FP (such as the percentage of the budget for essential drugs and health expenditures) ƒ Establish a line item in the national budget for FP ƒ Establish contraceptives as a strategic commodity ƒ Budget for family planning at the local level in decentralized settings ƒ Institutionalize the CS Committee LIST OF CS RESOURCES ƒ CS Index • Reproductive Health Supply Initiative • UNFPA • JSI – DELIVER Policy Briefs and Guidelines/Manuals/Software ƒ SPECTRUM ƒ PipeLine ƒ Macros DHS ƒ CDC RHS ‘International Reproductive Health Surveys and Survey Reports’ ƒ MSH Drugs Index International Drug Price Indicator Guide ƒ UNFPA contraceptive prices and CS materials RH commodities price list ƒ Maternal mortality strategy – PAHO ‘Regional Strategy for Maternal Mortality and Morbidity Reduction’ 2002 ƒ SPARHCS – ‘Strategic Pathway to Reproductive Health Commodity Security’ ƒ Market segmentation analyses, various countries (not available online) – available upon request ƒ LAC CS Regional Initiative • MEASURE Chapter on commodities and logistics ƒ Logistics indicator handbooks (forthcoming) ƒ CS Advocacy manual (forthcoming) ƒ Repositioning FP advocacy manual (forthcoming)

View the publication

Looking for other reproductive health publications?

The Supplies Information Database (SID) is an online reference library with more than 2000 records on the status of reproductive health supplies. The library includes studies, assessments and other publications dating back to 1986, many of which are no longer available even in their country of origin. Explore the database here.

You are currently offline. Some pages or content may fail to load.